The brick Cape Cod facade of 304 Old Courthouse Road, fronted by manicured boxwoods and blooming azaleas under a bright spring sky
Manhasset Hills · For Sale

A Cape Cod,
carefully kept.

304 Old Courthouse Road, New Hyde Park

Offered At
$1,250,000
4
Beds
2
Baths
1,504
Sq Ft
At A Glance

Eighty-five years of good bones, on a quiet Manhasset Hills street.

0
Bedrooms
0
Full Baths
0
Square Feet
0
Lot (Sq Ft)
0
Year Built
1
Car Garage
Property Type
Cape Cod
School District
Herricks UFSD
Heat / Cooking
Natural Gas
Parking
Garage + 4-Car Drive
On 304 Old Courthouse

Eighty-five springs of azaleas. The same oak floors underneath.

Built to last. Loved into shape.

Nestled in the heart of sought-after Manhasset Hills and located within the highly acclaimed Herricks Union Free School District, this 1941 Cape Cod has been quietly cared for across generations. The result is rare: a vintage home with original character intact, brought forward thoughtfully.

Four generously sized bedrooms. Two full baths. Oak hardwood floors that have aged into something better than new. Custom built-in closets in the dining room. Newer windows. Gas heat and gas cooking. 150-amp electric service. Abundant closet space throughout. The bones are excellent.

Outside, professionally landscaped grounds with in-ground sprinklers wrap the property, and a fully fenced private backyard sets the scene for entertaining or quiet evenings. New pavers lift the curb appeal to something truly singular for the block. A full basement, an attached one-car garage, and a long driveway that accommodates four cars round out the practical side.

Lake Success Shopping Center is minutes away. Michael J. Tully Park is around the corner. The Long Island Rail Road is about 1.75 miles to the nearest station. This is suburban Long Island the way it is meant to be lived.

What Makes It Singular

Five details, quietly considered.

01

A spacious living room with sun.

The main living space stretches the width of the home, with oak floors, traditional proportions, and full-height windows that pull in the eastern and southern light all afternoon.

02

Gas everything, modernized.

Natural gas heat and gas cooking, paired with newer windows and a 150-amp electric service. The mechanical systems have been kept current without touching the character of the home.

03

A backyard built for May.

Fully fenced for privacy. Professionally landscaped with in-ground sprinklers. A flat lawn ringed with mature evergreens and beds of azaleas that come into their full color the moment spring arrives.

04

Storage where you forget to look.

Custom built-in closets in the dining room. Abundant closet space throughout the bedrooms. A full basement with interior access to the attached one-car garage. The kind of square-footage-without-square-footage only old Cape Cods give you.

05

Four cars in the drive.

A long driveway accommodates up to four cars, plus the attached garage. Convenient for a household, generous for entertaining, rare for the street.

Estimate Your Payment

A private estimate, running quietly.

Adjust your down payment, rate, and term. We'll compute your monthly principal and interest in real time. No accounts, no email.

Down Payment 20%
$250,000 on a $1,250,000 list
Interest Rate 6.75%
Loan Term
Estimated Monthly Payment
$6,486
Loan Amount
$1,000,000
Term
30 Years

Principal and interest only. Estimate excludes property taxes, homeowner's insurance, and any HOA fees. For a fully scoped figure, your lender will be happy to run the math.

The Neighborhood

Manhasset Hills, as it lives.

Manhasset Hills sits at the western edge of Long Island's North Shore, a quiet residential pocket of New Hyde Park known for its tree-lined streets, single-family Cape Cods and colonials, and a sense of stay-put ownership.

The address falls inside the highly acclaimed Herricks Union Free School District, one of the most consistently top-rated public districts in the state. That alone defines the long-term character of the neighborhood.

Lake Success Shopping Center ~5 min
Michael J. Tully Park ~5 min
LIRR (New Hyde Park) ~1.75 mi
Manhattan via LIRR ~35 min
Herricks Schools Zoned
Schedule a Visit

Walk 304 Old Courthouse. In person, at your own pace.

Send your preferred days and we will confirm within twenty-four hours.

Direct line to the listing agent.
Open Sunday afternoons by appointment.
Representation
Listing Brokerage

Your Local Listing Agent

(516) 555 0100

Twenty years of stewardship across Manhasset Hills, North New Hyde Park, and the Herricks school district.

Pass It Along

Share the listing.

Scan To Revisit

Schedule a Tour